I Don’t Bake
You guys know that I’m not really into baking. The desserts category of my Recipes page is by far the shortest section, and most of them are frozen yogurts made up of various fruit combinations. But listen up friends. I am pleased to announce today that I baked a cake. Well, a sort of cake. I’m not a big sweets person, so don’t expect a big fluffy chocolate cake oozing with more chocolate. It’s a breakfast cake – or perhaps a loaf if you decide to make it in a loaf tin. And even though it’s not an iced cake/loaf, it’s still a pretty exciting one to wake up to in the morning.
You see, I’ve been getting a little bored of my usual cereal + yogurt + apple breakfast mix, and I was looking for a way to spice things up. Pumpkin spice things up, to be precise. Since this has been the only thing on my mind these days…
….naturally, I wanted to incorporate pumpkin in some capacity. I began building a recipe in my head based on the ingredients in my fridge. My goals included the following:
- Must have a strong pumpkin/pumpkin pie spice taste
- Must contain whole grains
- Must provide protein because I plan to eat it after my hard morning workouts
- Mustn’t be dry and cardboard-y
- Mustn’t be high in sugar
- Must be low in oil/butter if possible
- Must look like an actual cake, not like something my co-workers would give me odd looks for
My first trial went well, except it failed on 2 criteria. It was super dry and flaky, especially in the middle. I also had a very time getting it out of my round cake tin, even though I prepped it with oil beforehand.
Still… I had no trouble eating it. Really, aesthetics aside, it was pretty tasty!
The evening of my first trial, I went to bed thinking about my little baking project. Success was so close, I could almost taste it. Actually, I’d already tasted about 5 slices of it – but just slivers of course.
I woke up in the morning with a solution that came to me in my sleep.
Enter the springform pan. And yogurt. And unsweetened Almond Breeze. The pan for the sticking problem, and the yogurt and almond milk to remedy the lack of moisture. I was so excited about this that I drove to Wal Mart at 9am on Sunday morning to buy my pan. Thank you, Kaiser, for this wonderful invention.
I quickly drove home and got straight to work. A few other swaps were made – regular stevia instead of Krisda baking blend, a little more baking powder, and a bit more pumpkin pie spice, just because. The result was a thing of beauty.
Pumpkin Spiced High-Protein Breakfast Cake
Ingredients:
- 1 cup egg whites
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 9 packets stevia
- 1/3 cup fat-free plain or vanilla yogurt
- 1/2 cup unsweetened Almond Breeze
- 2 cups pumpkin puree
- 1/2 cup whole wheat pastry flour
- 1 cup rolled oats
- 6 scoops/about 1 1/2 cups vanilla whey protein, appx. 23g protein per scoop (Note: I haven’t tried this recipe with other types of protein, so I’m not sure how well they will work or if the cake would have the same consistency as it does with whey.)
- 2 tsp cinnamon
- 2 tsp pumpkin pie spice
- 1 tsp baking soda
- 1 tsp baking powder
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Mix the first 6 ingredients together in one bowl, and all remaining dry ingredients in another. Pour the wet ingredients into the bowl of dry ingredients, and stir until an even mixture forms. At this point, it’s crucial to do a taste test, because it will get you really excited for the end result. The batter is delicious, so take a good lick of the spoon.
Once you return from your sweet pumpkin-filled daydream, mist a springform pan with oil or spread a light coating of Earth Balance inside to prevent sticking. Empty the batter into the bowl and spread it around in an even layer.
Bake for 50-55 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the middle comes out clean.
Serves 12 (1 slice each).
Nutrition per serving: 118 calories, 2g fat (1g saturated), 35mg cholesterol, 168mg sodium, 11g carbs, 2g fiber, 2g sugar 16g protein.
Take a look at those stats!!! I kid you not, there are a whopping 16g of protein in each slice of this gorgeous gateau. Perfect for helping to repair your tired hard-working muscles post-workout.
This cake ticks all the boxes if you ask me – not too sweet, oil-free, strong pumpkin flavour, and moist inside. It also smells absolutely divine.
So what are you waiting for?








i love that photo of the cake + the pinecone! could be in a recipe calendar for “october!”
and very fun that you drove to walmart specifically for the pan…don’t you love when great a-ha! resolutions just hit!
nice job on your recipe invention, angela, and on doing some baking!
That looks good! I never used protein powder. I always hear a lot about it, but I don’t know how to use it or how much to use and if I need it.
In my previous experiences with making protein pancakes, waffles etc, I’ve found that whey protein seems to work the best. I’ll admit that the types I use aren’t totally “clean” – they do contain some sweeteners, natural and artificial depending on the brand. Casein protein provides a more dense texture, whereas I’ve found whey makes for more of a fluffy, light one. The scoops that come in the tubs I have measure out to be about 1/4 cup each, and I think that’s pretty standard across brands.
I really like this recipe! It’s great for those chilly fall mornings
This looks great!
The texture looks perfect!
That looks really delicious! Nicely done!
For someone who’s not into baking, this looks great. I never used to be, but recently I haven’t been able to get enough of it… not good for my waistline
I can’t believe you made up your own recipe! Bravo, Angela! Well done.
Do you think you can nix the protein powder from this recipe and still get a good result?
Probably! I’d be interested to know if it turns out using all whole wheat pastry flour. I would be hesitant to use straight up whole wheat flour because I think it’d make the cake too heavy, but whole wheat pastry flour is probably a good bet. Let me know if you experiment with it!
I made this last night, but substituted Bob’s Red Mill Low-Carb baking mix -worked out well, too! This is a great recipe:)
Wow, you didn’t waste any time there!! So glad you enjoyed it!
Hilarious how you raised our expectations to the level of a big iced chocolate cake but before we even got to the end of the first paragraph we were at a “muffin in a loaf pan”. LOL Can’t wait to try a veganized verison of this. I like breakfast items I can make on Sunday and my son can just grab and go during the week.
thanks again. love love love your blog.
Haha well let’s look at it this way: Iced baked goods can be difficult to travel with, but loaves and muffins on the other hand – no mess there!!
Thanks for commenting Tonya!
Cake for breakfast is the best! Congrats on your baking project
Your pumpkin cake looks amazing! I pretty much like anything with pumpkin in it though. Also loving all your fall decor!
Thanks Beth! I might need to get some more though… you guys will probably get tired of looking at the same pinecones and leaves after a while!
That looks great! I just posted the other day about Pumpkin PB & Oat bars and I love that you said this “Must have a strong pumpkin/pumpkin pie spice taste” <– me too. Or what's the point
Those sound divine! I’ll check em out!
yum!! ive been meaning to bake something like this- pumpkiny and low fat. will def be trying this one!! THANKS!
For “not baking” you executed this very well!! Looks amazing!
That looks ridiculously good. I love dense, moist cakes…actually more than the light, fluffy ones.
I’m the opposite! I would much rather bake something than use a skillet!
[...] on to the fabulous fall fare. Earlier this week, I spotted a delicious pumpkin spice high protein cake on Eat Spin Run Repeat. The recipe sounded great and gave me inspiration to create a new recipe [...]
curious to know what size springform pan you used
Just measured it – it was a 9 inch pan.
Hi!
Do you have any idea how to make this into a gluten-free cake without using pre-made gluten-free baking mixes?
Thanks
Hmmm… I think you could probably sub out the whole wheat pastry flour for something like brown rice flour or quinoa flour, and use gluten free oats rather than the regular kind (I know Bob’s Red Mill has GF oats but have never tried them myself). Let me know if it works out!